Cutting Your Losses
Cutting Your Losses
I lost a friend, but I'm not losing money anymore. I should also point out that the investments
I made on my own during that time made excellent gains. And what's most relevant about
that example isn't so much the broker story as it is the fact that I made more money by
managing my own investments. Had I lost more money through my own transactions, that
would have been okay, too. At least I would have been responsible either way since I was
making my own decisions regarding my money.
The point is this-control your own money in all aspects. This means that even if you do hire
a professional to help you, you are still responsible for ensuring that the person you choose is
effectively doing exactly what you hired him or her to accomplish. Make sure then, that you
periodically reevaluate their performance. Don't get sidetracked by things like emotion or
friendship. As with any professionals, if they are not cutting the mustard, get rid of them and
hire someone better.
The Loyal Loser
The Loyal Loser
For example, I personally fall into that last category. A couple of years ago I hired a full
service broker from a well-known firm for some of my accounts. She was a nice young
person, and I liked her so much that I was loath to leave her
even though I consistently lost
money with her management. I took the losses without saying a word, because I figured we
were friends. So did she-until she got a promotion and turned over all her portfolios to a
replacement. The new broker was even nicer and friendlier than the first, but she was a
goner before she unpacked her nametag. I closed my account immediately.
The point here is that I was looking to make a profit, not new friends. The first broker, really,
was a nice person, and probably used a lot of that friendliness to keep clients such as me.
She certainly wasn't keeping clients because of the profits we were making.
As for the second broker, I never lost a cent, but that was because I finally wised up to the
fact that I was keeping these professionals on my payroll because they were friendly, not
effective. Who would keep a plumber on staff when all the faucets still leak? In all fairness,
the replacement broker may have been poised to make me a great deal of profit, but I had
decided by that point to take control of my money and manage it myself.
Full Service Stockbrokers
Full Service Stockbrokers
You can find full service stockbrokers at the most well-known and established companies,
including
Salomon Smith Barney
Morgan Stanley
Goldman Sachs
Merrill Lynch
For all their eminent reputations, however, brokerage firms use a substantially different track
for selling stock than the average investor would think. The company that uses the
expression about making money the old-fashioned way-earning it-isn't lying. They just
didn't specify for
whom they were making that old-fashioned money.
Bluntly put, stockbrokers have to make a living, too. And that lifestyle isn't cheap. Did I
mention that full service brokers also charge the highest commissions? I've heard of full
service brokers who charge up to $75 per transaction. Even though the average investor may
be aware of these commissions, what goes largely unsaid is the other ways in which
stockbrokers make money or further their business.
You should know upfront that in all fairness, full service brokers and brokerages have their
uses and place within investment. Many people, for a variety of reasons, do utilize the
services of full service brokers and brokerages and do very well by them.
For example, someone with enough money in the market to prohibit the time needed to
effectively keep track of investment trends (because the person is using all that time to make
the money that's being invested) would make a good candidate for a full service broker.
Also, someone who was planning to buy and/or sell on a daily basis is an example of
someone who might fare well using the services of a broker. Although this type of client,
however, would still do well to consider excessive service fees involved in these kinds of
services. In addition, most stockbrokers aren't dishonest and do play upfront with their
clients. After all, unhappy clients will leave sooner or later, so it's in the stockbroker's best
interest to keep them happy.
The average stockbroker, however, does have to make a living. So, for example, a
stockbroker with his or her huge wealth of knowledge tells you that purchasing stock in XYZ
Company is the single best thing you can do. You invest as the stockbroker tells you to; after
all, who are you to second-guess the stockbroker? You're a dentist with little or no knowledge
of how all this works, whereas the broker has years of experience and access to a substantial
amount of firm research- usually from within the brokerage house itself. So, the stockbroker
takes a commission for placing the purchase order. The stockbroker is happy; you're happy.
What could be wrong?
Did the stockbroker mention that the reason you should buy XYZ Company stock is also
because he or she needs to sell a certain amount of XYZ Company's stock in order to retain
his or her account, and the broker was running pretty close to the end of the month without
having reached that quota? Or did the stockbroker mention that the company is giving him or
her a cut of the sale out of the backside for each share the broker places with a client? The
stockbroker wasn't lying about XYZ Company stock being the best purchase you could make.
The broker just failed to mention that the payday was his or hers, not yours.
Also, the "research" that you thought would make a difference, and that went largely
unnoticed in this transaction was flawed anyway. The analysts who compile this research are
under extraordinary pressure from upper management as well as from the clients themselves
to back up the interests of the company. Not necessarily to lie, mind you, but to present the
information in its best-or in the case of the competitor, the worst-possible light.
CAUTION
A full service broker usually manages his or her client's account directly and charges
the highest commissions.
And finally, from personal experience, many people develop a good working relationship with
their brokers and a strong sense of loyalty keeps them as clients. Even in these situations,
however, be aware of the whole story.
.
Securities and Exchange Commission
Securities and Exchange Commission
The
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is the U.S. Government commission
charged with the responsibility of ensuring compliance with its securities act. Through the use
of its own financial professionals, which includes qualified stockbrokers, the SEC monitors
trading and the markets through the computerized networks for strange and/or unusual
trading activity, for example. These professionals would then further investigate to uncover
illegal activity such as insider trading (trading with prior or nonpublic information). To
eliminate conflict of interests, SEC financial professionals do not engage in professional
trading activity themselves, but work for and are compensated exclusively by the U.S.
Government.
Role of Stockbrokers
Role of Stockbrokers
The term
broker has been used to describe financial transaction agents since the
seventeenth century. Brokers are part of a bigger category known as investment bankers, a
group that is also not new. Investment bankers have been around since at least the Middle
Ages when they were responsible for raising the monies necessary for kings and queens to
wage war on one another. The adjective "investment" describing banker only means that the
banker focuses on investment as opposed to other banker functions such as retail banking,
which deals with such things as checking and savings for the general public.
Modern standards are substantially less dramatic and violent. A stockbroker today is a
person who has passed a test called a Series 7 Exam administered by the Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC) and, as such, has the necessary qualifications to buy and sell
stock for his or her clients. A brokerage firm is nothing more than a firm composed of, you
guessed it, stockbrokers.
What kind of people become stockbrokers? Those who obviously have some sort of interest
in finance, economics, and the stock market. This would be necessary, as the Series 7 exam
is not easy and the career of a stockbroker, because of the high pressure, is generally pretty
short (about two to three years). For those reasons, most brokerage houses will pay for new
brokers to take classes, similar to preparing for the SAT, and even pay for the new broker to
take the exam. The new broker would then, however, be committed to work for the brokerage
house for a period of time, again, usually a couple of years. Most of the people who go
through this are also attracted by the availability of high income. As brokers work on
commission, their pay is directly tied to how motivated they are to sell stock. An aggressive
broker can make hundreds of thousands, or even millions of dollars per year.
In addition to having the qualifications including licensing and knowledge of stocks and the
markets, brokers are the only ones legally permitted to buy and sell stock, so they've got a
lock on the market. Like it or not, you've got to use a broker or brokerage firm to buy stocks.
Luckily, since the abolishment of standardized broker fees in 1975, many different types and
price structures for stockbrokers now exist. Everyone has access to any number of
competing firms, so you can pick the type of broker or brokerage that is most applicable to
your needs.
Types of Stockbrokers
Types of Stockbrokers
Stocks are available for sale through stockbrokers. You can find many listings for brokers in
Appendix B, "Resources,"
at the end of this book, in the financial pages of your local
newspaper, or even in your local Yellow Pages. You will find
Full service brokers
Discount brokers
E-brokers
Brokers and Brokerage Houses
Brokers and Brokerage Houses
In this lesson you will learn about the various types of stockbrokers and about brokerage
houses where you can purchase stock.
Other Markets
Other Markets
In addition to the markets already discussed, which deal primarily with stock, a number of
different markets exist to service the trades of derivatives, options, futures, and other stocklike
investments. These niche exchanges are of great importance to their particular products,
although their exchanges may not be as widely known.
The Chicago Board of Trade, for example, deals almost exclusively with the exchange of
grain futures. The New York Cotton Exchange deals with cotton, of course. These specialty
markets rarely make for exciting financial news, yet the Chicago Board of Trade, for example,
is one of the most important exchanges in the world. A day's activity here could determine
changes in the
consumer price index, an indicator that measures the percentage of change
of the cost of goods and services in well-developed nations and that also measures the end
or beginning of famine in emerging markets.
Plain English
Remember that stock index explanation from Lesson 6, whereby an average would
indicate whether the price of everything in the market had gone up? The consumer
price index is the same thing, except that instead of averaging the cost of stock or
a farmer's market, it averages the cost of all things the average person in this
country buys, like food, clothing, and utilities.
Most of these exchanges operate on basically the same principle as the stock exchanges,
but their clientele as well as their purpose are usually substantially more specific. In addition,
the governing entities may be different from their stock exchange counterparts. The
exchange of futures, for example, is regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading
Commission (CFTC) rather than by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Like
stock exchanges, these various exchanges are located around the country, in Chicago,
Minneapolis, and Phil-adelphia, as well as around the world, in Paris, Winnipeg, and Sydney.
Finally, be aware that in the past the activity of these various exchanges could be a little
more difficult to find. Usually only the very large financial publications such as The Wall
Street Journal or corresponding local publications carried the reports. Fortunately, today's
computers and dedicated financial media are so broad that information on any of these
markets is usually available at the touch of a button.
The Big Bang
The Big Bang
Even if you don't actually own stock in foreign companies, their performance can provide
great insight into the future performance of the American markets. The day of the
Big Bang
marked the beginning of a global market. As the increased globalization of trades continues,
the effects of a day's trading around the world will continue to directly affect the performance
of other international markets. A recent example was the collapse of many Asian markets, an
event that dealt a fierce blow to the stability of the American markets. International investors
who were awake during the open hours of Asian trading were aware of the impending
damage hours before the American exchanges even opened. In this particular example, I'm
proud to say that the American markets were strong enough to withstand the blow, and the
damage was quickly repaired.
Plain English
The Big Bang was a red-letter day in trading history. On October 27, 1986, the
London Stock Exchange dropped its restrictions on allowing foreign investors to
participate in their markets. Symbolically, this day represents the unification of
markets around the world into one global marketplace.
International Exchanges
International Exchanges
The scope of American finance is absolutely unparalleled anywhere else on the globe. The
American economy is somewhere around 16 times the size of its closest competitor. The
sixth largest economy on the face of the earth, for example, is that of the State of California.
For all its size, however, the U.S. economy does not, by any stretch of the imagination, stand
alone. Exchanges and financial markets all over the world, through the use of today's
computerized systems, have created a world where stocks trade 24 hours per day.
Exchanges exist in almost every major city in the world, including Paris, London, Frankfurt,
Tokyo, Johannesburg, Sidney, Hong Kong, and Singapore. While every one of these
exchanges directly affects, and is directly affected by, each other, they are all under the
authority of their own governments and must follow their government's laws. As a result, they
differ from each as much as they are the same. While learning about international markets is
interesting, actually investing in them as an individual is an altogether different matter. As a
general rule, most international investing is done by corporate entities such as banks or
mutual funds which then provide opportunities for international investments domestically
through the use of ADRs or globally invested funds.
CAUTION
Moving money and stock from country to country is a very difficult transaction as a
result of conflicting tax structures, exchange rates, and permissible investments.
In addition, although the activities of the international exchanges are not as widely reported in
the United States as those of our own exchanges, that fact in no way reflects badly on the
prestige or importance of these markets. Several of these exchanges, for example, predate
the founding of either or both of the major American exchanges. London claims the world's
oldest stock exchange, having been founded in 1773.
The results of the day's trading in international exchanges are readily available in the United
States, though the reports are not as extensive as for the U.S. exchanges. Many financial
publications list the results of any day's trades in a number of financial markets.
The Wall
Street Journal and The New York Times both publish the results of the most actively traded
stocks worldwide.
Small Fry Regional Exchanges
Small Fry Regional Exchanges
Regional exchanges conduct their own proprietary business as well business for their bigger
counterparts. The requirements for a company to have its stock listed on the two major
exchanges are often prohibitive for many smaller companies. However, these companies can
usually meet the requirements of the smaller exchanges and for that reason are traded there.
For example, in the same burger joint scenario let's say you are a lobster fisherman. You
know that the national burger joint has no interest in your new product, the Lobster Burger. In
Maine, however, the Lobster Burger is a big hit. Rather than attempting to sell your Lobster
Burger to Burger Joint headquarters for distribution in all its locations, you take your Lobster
Burger idea directly to Burger Joint headquarters for the State of Maine. They agree to
distribute, or sell, your Lobster Burger exclusively through Maine. In the same way, a regional
exchange offers access to markets where many smaller companies can remain competitive.
Regional Exchanges
Regional Exchanges
The two principal markets in the United States, the NYSE and AMEX, can actively trade only
a minuscule proportion of the total number of shares in the United States. For that reason, 14
other smaller exchanges, which are scattered around the country, are linked to the NYSE
and the AMEX in order to help them trade stock more quickly and effectively. These
exchanges, known as
regional ex-changes, operate the same as the two big exchanges, and
often even duplicate their work.
Some of the better-known regional exchanges are …
Pacific Stock Exchange
Boston Stock Exchange
Midwest Stock Exchange
Philadelphia Stock Exchange
These exchanges, while perhaps not quite as well known as NYSE and AMEX, are significant
in their own right for many reasons. The Philadelphia Stock Exchange, for example, has the
distinction of being this country's first stock exchange. Its founding in 1790 predates the
founding of the NYSE by more than a quarter of a century, and the founding of AMEX by
over half a century.
Again, many of these exchanges trade the same stocks as their bigger counterparts to help
reduce the load that the major exchanges are expected to service. At the end of the day, the
results of trading a particular stock are added up from all locations and reported to the
general public as composite trading.
Think of the situation as a burger joint. The entire country couldn't walk into the same burger
joint and expect to be served within a reasonable time frame. So, the burger joint opens up
locations all over the country, and they all offer the same food to their customers. In the same
way, the regional exchanges offer the same stocks for trade to local investors as the big ones
do. At the end of the day, however, management wants to know how many burgers were sold
at all locations. After adding together the sales at all locations, the resulting total number of
burgers sold is known as the burger joint's composite trading figure.
The American Stock Exchange
The American Stock Exchange
The
American Stock Exchange (AMEX) is also based in New York and has a great tale of
origin. In 1842 men who were not considered "gentlemanly enough" to be admitted into the
New York Stock Exchange stood outside the building, trading stocks on the curb and yelling
and hollering loud enough to ensure that they were being heard by the "gentlemen" inside.
These rabble-rousers, known as the New York Curb Exchange, traded stocks in this manner
until 1921 when they finally moved indoors. Subsequently, in 1953 this exchange changed its
name to The American Stock Exchange.
Plain English
The American Stock Exchange is the New York Stock Exchange's rival trading 900
of the nation's largest stock to the NYSE's 1,600. In addition, the AMEX requires the
issuing company to maintain a balance of $4 million in assets to the NYSE's
minimum requirement of $18 million.
The New York Stock Exchange
The New York Stock Exchange
Back in 1792, 24 men showed up to trade stocks under a buttonwood tree and pronounced
that location as their future stock-trading marketplace. The road next to the buttonwood tree
had been named for a blockade wall built earlier to keep Manhattan settlers safe from
marauding Indians and pirates. I'm not making this up. That market and its humble
beginnings eventually evolved into today's mammoth New York Stock Exchange, and the
corresponding road next to the blockade wall became known as Wall Street, synonymous
with today's financial world.
Plain English
The
markets is a term referring to the centralized physical locations and the
computer networks at which the business of trading stocks is conducted.
Trading Places
Trading Places
So, where are all these trades taking place? Way before there was money, people used to
trade items to each other. If I had a goat and you wanted it, you'd offer me three chickens in
trade, and we'd both go off happy. If someone else offered me four chickens, or if someone
else showed up with a bigger goat, there would probably be a lot of yelling involved.
Eventually, people finally figured out that they'd save time looking for other people with whom
to trade if they regularly showed up at one designated location where everyone brought
something to trade.
With the introduction of money, these trades evolved into purchases and sales. Thousands
of years later, the market concept is still very much alive. People who want to buy or sell
stocks figure that showing up at the same location at the same time to trade stocks is a pretty
good idea. Today, over 140 physical exchanges buy and sell trillions of shares of hundreds of
thousands of stocks 24 hours per day. Although those figures are mind-boggling, they
represent only a small fraction of the trades being conducted over computerized networks.
Here are the markets:
New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
The largest physical stock exchange in the world.
American Stock Exchange (AMEX).
The rival of the NYSE in size and prestige.
Regional exchanges.
Fourteen exchanges located around the United States.
Over the counter.
A term for stocks traded over a computerized network called the National Market
System (NMS).
International exchanges.
Stock exchanges in other countries.
Other markets.
Markets where the trading of financial instruments other than stocks, such as futures,
options, and money, is conducted.
The Markets
The Markets
In this lesson you will learn about the physical locations where stock is available for trade and
also about computerized networks over which stock is available for trade